I want to believe but I can't make myself. Is that my fault?
Last updated: 2026-08-14
I want to believe but I can't make myself. Is that my fault?
The Short Answer
The struggle to believe is common for all who grapple with their own brokenness, and while the guilt for unbelief rests upon the human heart, the capacity to trust Christ is the free and sovereign gift of God. Because faith is not an achievement of your own will but a work of the Spirit, you are encouraged to look away from your own inability and instead rest in the sufficiency of the one who commands you to trust Him.
The Nature of Our Inability
Mark 9:24, Institutes of the Christian Religion — Chapter 2: OF FAITH. THE DEFINITION OF IT. ITS PECULIAR PROPERTIES.
The Nature of Our Inability
Mark 9:24, Institutes of the Christian Religion — Chapter 2: OF FAITH. THE DEFINITION OF IT. ITS PECULIAR PROPERTIES.
The Scriptures acknowledge the deep tension between the command to believe and the frailty of our human nature. When the father in the Gospel brings his son to Jesus, he candidly confesses, 'I believe; help thou mine unbelief' (Mark 9:24 ASV). This illustrates that even when a seed of faith is present, we are often plagued by an internal, natural bias toward doubt. Reformed theology identifies this as a consequence of the fall; the mind and heart are not neutral, but are often 'retarded and impeded' by ignorance and sin (Institutes of the Christian Religion — Chapter 2: OF FAITH. THE DEFINITION OF IT. ITS PECULIAR PROPERTIES. §20). Consequently, we find ourselves unable to stir up true, saving faith by mere force of will, as we are 'prone to unbelief' by our natural constitution (Institutes of the Christian Religion — Chapter 2: OF FAITH. THE DEFINITION OF IT. ITS PECULIAR PROPERTIES. §20).
Unbelief as Human Responsibility
Canons of Dort — Head 1: Of Divine Predestination, Article 5, Canons of Dort — Head 2: Of the Death of Christ, and the Redemption of Men Thereby, Article 5
Unbelief as Human Responsibility
Canons of Dort — Head 1: Of Divine Predestination, Article 5, Canons of Dort — Head 2: Of the Death of Christ, and the Redemption of Men Thereby, Article 5
While our inability is real, the Reformed tradition is careful to maintain that the blame for unbelief remains with the individual, not with God. The Canons of Dort — Head 1: Of Divine Predestination, Article 5 clearly states that the guilt of unbelief is in no wise in God, but in man himself. When people reject the gospel, it is not due to a deficiency in the sacrifice of Christ, but is 'wholly to be imputed to themselves' (Canons of Dort — Head 2: Of the Death of Christ, and the Redemption of Men Thereby, Article 5). This prevents the despair of thinking that God is the author of our rebellion. We are responsible creatures, yet we are also dependent creatures. This reality, while seemingly paradoxical, guards the truth that we are justly held accountable for our hardness of heart, even while we are simultaneously unable to overcome that heart's enmity without the intervention of sovereign grace.
Faith as a Gift, Not a Merit
Institutes of the Christian Religion — Chapter 2: OF FAITH. THE DEFINITION OF IT. ITS PECULIAR PROPERTIES., The Death of Death in the Death of Christ — Chapter Iv.
Faith as a Gift, Not a Merit
Institutes of the Christian Religion — Chapter 2: OF FAITH. THE DEFINITION OF IT. ITS PECULIAR PROPERTIES., The Death of Death in the Death of Christ — Chapter Iv.
If faith were a work of our own will, we would have cause to boast in ourselves; however, Scripture identifies it as a work of God (Institutes of the Christian Religion — Chapter 2: OF FAITH. THE DEFINITION OF IT. ITS PECULIAR PROPERTIES. §35). Faith is not a commodity we produce to 'pay' for salvation; it is the fruit of the Holy Spirit's operation in us. John Owen argued that to suggest faith is merely an act of our own power, independent of grace, is to undermine the very nature of the New Covenant, which promises that God will 'effectually work' its conditions in all his people (The Death of Death in the Death of Christ — Chapter Iv. §1). Because Christ purchased for his people not just the opportunity for salvation but the gift of faith itself, we may look to him to grant what we cannot generate. Our inability is the starting point for receiving this gift, as we are brought to the end of our own strength to lean entirely upon his.
Practical Steps in the Life of Grace
All of Grace — Chapter 12: The Increase of Faith
Practical Steps in the Life of Grace
All of Grace — Chapter 12: The Increase of Faith
Given that faith is the work of the Spirit, we must pursue the means he has ordained. Charles Spurgeon advises that the 'shortest way to believe is to believe' (All of Grace — Chapter 12: The Increase of Faith). We often waste time 'discussing methods' while ignoring the simple command to trust. If you are struggling, go to God in prayer and tell him exactly what puzzles you; ask him to solve your doubts through his Word (All of Grace — Chapter 12: The Increase of Faith). Faith often comes by hearing the gospel repeatedly, allowing the truth to take root as the Spirit blesses the testimony of others and the promises of Scripture. Do not look within yourself for the 'faith' to believe; look to the object of faith—Jesus Christ. Think upon who He is and what He has done. He has not given you reason to distrust him; rather, He commands your trust as your Maker. By studying the Evangelists and the epistles, you expose your mind to the very atmosphere where the Spirit creates belief.
Sources
7 works cited
Mark 9:24 · ASV
Straightway the father of the child cried out, and said, I believe; help thou mine unbelief.
American Standard Version (1901) · Public domainExternal link
Institutes of the Christian Religion — Chapter 2: OF FAITH. THE DEFINITION OF IT. ITS PECULIAR PROPERTIES. §20
In such degrees of ignorance much doubt and trembling is necessarily implied, especially seeing that our heart is by its own natural bias prone to unbelief.
Affiliate link · Free-source search opens Google (ads supported)
Canons of Dort — Head 1: Of Divine Predestination, Article 5
The cause or guilt of this unbelief as well as of all other sins, is no wise in God, but in man himself; whereas faith in Jesus Christ, and salvation through him is the free gift of God
External link · Free-source search opens Google (ads supported)
Canons of Dort — Head 2: Of the Death of Christ, and the Redemption of Men Thereby, Article 5
The cause or guilt of this unbelief as well as of all other sins, is no wise in God, but in man himself; whereas faith in Jesus Christ, and salvation through him is the free gift of God, as it is written: "By grace ye are saved through faith, and that not of yourselves, it is the gift of God," Ephes
External link · Free-source search opens Google (ads supported)
Institutes of the Christian Religion — Chapter 2: OF FAITH. THE DEFINITION OF IT. ITS PECULIAR PROPERTIES. §35
20. The Apostle elegantly adverts to both in different passages. When he says, "We know in part, and we prophesy in part;" and "Now we see through a glass darkly," (1 Cor. 13:9, 12), he intimates how very minute a portion of divine wisdom is given to us in the present life. For although those expres
Affiliate link · Free-source search opens Google (ads supported)
The Death of Death in the Death of Christ — Chapter Iv. §1
it is wholly situated in our power to perform that spiritual act, nothing being bestowed upon us by free grace, in and through Christ (as was before declared), but what by him, in his death and oblation, was procured: which is contrary, -- (1.) To express Scripture in exceeding many places
Affiliate link · Free-source search opens Google (ads supported)
All of Grace — Chapter 12: The Increase of Faith
could walk on it? He declared that he believed a great many things the missionary had told him; but he would never believe that. When he came to England it came to pass that one frosty day he saw the river frozen, but he would not venture on it. He knew that it was a deep river, and he felt certain
Affiliate link · Free-source search opens Google (ads supported)
Scripture quotations are from the American Standard Version (1901), which is in the public domain.
