Essay

Does AI have a place in studying God?

The worry about AI and theology is a good one. It belongs to the study Bible and the small-group workbook too.

Does AI have a place in studying theology, or in studying God at all? I think it does, and I think it can do a lot of good for Christians who want to know God better. But the question is older than AI, so I'll start there.

Every tool has raised this question

The printing press put Scripture and Luther's writings in front of people who had never owned a book. Translation put the Bible in the language people spoke at home. Concordances, commentaries, study Bibles, Bible software and search followed. Each one made the text easier to get at, and each time someone had to ask whether easier meant shallower.

Even a new translation of the same text has met it. When the Revised Standard Version put "young woman" at Isaiah 7:14 in 1952, a pastor in Rocky Mount, North Carolina, burned the page in front of his congregation. New tools tend to get this on the way in, while everyone, Christians included, works out what to do with them.

AI is the next one, and it is different in one way that matters: it answers back. You can ask it the question you have, in the words you would use, without knowing where in a systematic theology the answer lives.

A question at youth group

I have worked with youth, on and off, for twenty years. At youth group, an eleventh grader once asked me whether Jehovah's Witnesses are Christians.

We talked about where the theology differs, and about the old error their teaching about Christ resembles, the one Arius taught about 1,700 years ago. From there we went to the Nicene Creed, in the form churches recite today, which the church wrote to answer that error, and then to the Bible, and we talked through some of the specific points.

The church did the hard work at Nicaea; I only knew where to look. What that student had, and plenty of kids do not, was a room with someone in it to ask. Many of them are not in a room with anyone weekly, and the question comes as they fall asleep or when they are cornered at school.

That is where I think AI can help. A good tool can do part of what happened in that room. It can name the difference, show where the church has already argued it out, point to the creed, and send the kid to the text, at the hour the question comes up and in the words the kid used. I build one of these tools, so weigh what I say with that in mind. I started building it because of kids like that one, and I am still learning what it is good for.

The worry is a good one

Luther, in the 1539 preface to his German writings, gave three rules for studying theology: prayer, meditation, and Anfechtung, the assault that comes to a person who holds the Word. He also warned against anyone who seizes on Scripture with his own reason, without prayer, and becomes his own teacher. The Westminster Larger Catechism puts its weight on preaching, and asks hearers to come with diligence, preparation and prayer, to test what they hear against Scripture, and to meditate and confer about it.

I agree with all of that. The sharpest form of the objection is that a tool that answers back is not a concordance. It imitates the person in the room, and a kid who has it may never go looking for the room. A machine cannot pray with you, and it cannot stand with you under Anfechtung. The objector is right that whatever a tool gives, it is not that.

The rest of the worry is older than machines, and the same questions belong to the helps that already sit on a Christian's shelf. The Geneva Bible of 1560 carried its notes in the margins. They read the text in a Reformed way and carried enough politics that King James called them seditious, and when he ordered a new translation in 1604 he ordered it with no notes beyond what the Hebrew and Greek required. In 1909 the Scofield Reference Bible printed its notes on the same page as the King James text, and a whole system for reading the Bible, with its own timetable for the end of the age, travelled in those notes to millions of readers. A note under a verse borrows the verse's authority. On the page it does not say who wrote it, what he assumed, or who disagrees.

The catechism already asks this of the sermon itself. Hearers are to "examine what they hear by the Scriptures" (Westminster Larger Catechism, Q160), which is what Luke praised the Bereans for: "examining the Scriptures daily, whether these things were so" (Acts 17:11). If that is owed to the preacher, it is owed to the study note and to the machine. It is owed as well to the small-group workbook, which arrives with a publisher's logo and an author's photo and was handed to the leader on Sunday. The questions people now put to AI are the right ones: who is speaking, can I open the source, who disagrees. We should have been asking them of paper all along.

The worry marks out what the tool is for. A concordance never replaced a congregation, and neither did a study Bible. The old Reformed way to put it is that reason and tradition serve Scripture and do not rule it. AI belongs in the same place as a concordance or a good commentary. It helps you reach the text faster, ask the question you were embarrassed to ask, and see what the church has already said. Then you take what you found back to your pastor, your family and your small group.

Where I have landed

AI is going to be part of the future, and Christians, myself included, are still working out how it fits into every part of our lives, our walk with God among them.

What I am confident of is narrower. A research tool that answers in conversation, which is what I am trying to build with AskCredo, lets a person ask in their own words and dig down to good theology without first reading thousands of pages of Luther or four volumes of Bavinck, and without holding the whole Bible in memory. The simplest question can open onto the deepest conversation, and that conversation should not end with the machine.

What I would check in any answer

The four questions from my last essay work on any tool, and on any study note. Who is speaking: Scripture and the confessions, or the machine's own summary? Can you open the sources, and does the source say what the answer says it does? On a contested question, does it say who disagrees, or does it settle the matter itself? And does it act like your pastor? If it does, be wary.

What I would ask of churches

If you lead kids, the thing that mattered most in that story was the room. Keep one open. When a question comes, take it to where the church has already argued it out: the difference, the creed, the text. The kids you cannot be with will ask a machine anyway, so know what the one they use will tell them. And put the four questions to the curriculum you buy or search for, not only to the apps your kids use.

What that conversation came down to is all I would ask of anyone. Open the text, then the creed the church wrote to guard it, and take what you find to someone in a room.

More essays
Ask a follow-up about this topic
Ask a follow-up