As a Jew, why should I believe Jesus is the Messiah if he suffered and died instead of reigning?
Last updated: 2026-08-31
As a Jew, why should I believe Jesus is the Messiah if he suffered and died instead of reigning?
The Short Answer
The expectation of a reigning Messiah is deeply rooted in the Hebrew Scriptures, but those same Scriptures also clearly foretell a Suffering Servant who must first bear the iniquity of the people. Rather than contradicting the messianic hope, Jesus' death and resurrection fulfill the necessary work of atonement that permits Him to establish an everlasting, spiritual kingdom that will culminate in His visible reign over all creation.
The Dual Hope of the Scriptures
Isaiah 53:1-12
The Dual Hope of the Scriptures
Isaiah 53:1-12
The tension between a triumphant King and a suffering servant is a central feature of the Hebrew prophetic tradition. While the post-exilic expectation largely focused on a political deliverer who would restore the throne of David and defeat Israel's oppressors, the prophetic texts themselves hold a deeper, more profound mystery. Isaiah 53:1-12 ASV presents a Servant who is 'despised and rejected,' 'pierced for our transgressions,' and 'crushed for our iniquities.' This figure does not merely face external foes; He deals with the internal, spiritual sickness of humanity—sin itself. The prophet declares that it was the 'will of Jehovah to bruise him,' making His soul an 'offering for sin' (v. 10). This suffering is not a mark of failure but the divinely ordained path to victory. The Servant is 'cut off out of the land of the living' precisely for the transgression of God's people, and through this act, He 'shall see of the travail of his soul, and shall be satisfied.' The Scriptures indicate that before the Messiah can reign over the nations, He must first secure the redemption of His people from the debt of sin that keeps them in exile from God.
The Necessity of Atonement
Heidelberg Catechism Q37
The Necessity of Atonement
Heidelberg Catechism Q37
The logic of the Torah, established in the Levitical sacrificial system, dictates that atonement for sin requires a life given—blood shed in the place of the guilty. The Heidelberg Catechism Q37 reflects the Reformed conviction that Jesus' suffering was not an accident but a necessary, propitiatory sacrifice to redeem body and soul from 'everlasting damnation.' Without this final, perfect sacrifice, the problem of human iniquity remains. Prophets like Zechariah foresaw a day when the inhabitants of Jerusalem would look upon the One they pierced and mourn for Him as for an only son, acknowledging their own part in His suffering (Zechariah 12:10 ASV). As scholars such as David Baron have observed, if the Messiah were only a political conqueror, the profound moral and spiritual problem of human sin—the obstacle that prevents true fellowship with a holy God—would remain unaddressed. Jesus' death addresses the root cause of the exile; by bearing the curse of the law, He opens the way for the restoration that the prophets promised. He is the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world, making the covenant promise of restoration a reality.
A Kingdom Not of This World
Acts 13:27-52
A Kingdom Not of This World
Acts 13:27-52
The New Testament does not replace the kingdom promises made to Israel but clarifies their nature. The rulers of Jerusalem expected a king to break Rome, but Jesus proclaimed a kingdom that begins in the heart and extends to the ends of the earth. In Acts 13:27-39 ASV, Paul explains that Jesus fulfilled the prophecies of the suffering and resurrection exactly as the prophets wrote. By rising from the dead, Jesus demonstrated that His death was not a defeat but a triumph over the 'power of death' itself. Because He conquered death, He is the only One who can truly reign forever. The promises made to David—that his throne would be established forever—find their ultimate fulfillment in the resurrected Christ, who now sits at the right hand of God, waiting for the time when every knee shall bow. The 'reigning' you seek is not absent; it is currently established through the preaching of the gospel and the gathering of all nations to the God of Abraham. As the Scriptures indicate, the Messiah was to be a 'light for the Gentiles' (v. 47), bringing salvation to the ends of the earth. The church looks forward to the day when this kingdom, currently spiritual and invisible, will be fully manifested in the return of Christ to judge the living and the dead.
Also cited: Acts 13:27-52 ASV
Cross-tradition Comparison: Jewish-Christian Perspectives
Judaism, Continuity, and the Charge of Supersessionism
Cross-tradition Comparison: Jewish-Christian Perspectives
Judaism, Continuity, and the Charge of Supersessionism
Within the wider Reformed and Christian heritage, there is a consistent effort to honor the Jewish roots of the faith. The Anglican tradition, as expressed in the Books of Homilies, emphasizes that while the Jewish expectation of a political conqueror remained a 'stumbling block,' the witness of the apostles confirms Jesus as the true Mediator between God and man. Meanwhile, scholars like David Baron and Alfred Edersheim—both of Jewish background—argued that the categories the New Testament uses (Messiah, Son of Man, Word of God) are profoundly Jewish. They insist that the Gospel is not 'replacement theology' but the fulfillment of the Abrahamic covenant. The Reformed view generally aligns with this, teaching that God has not cast off His people. As Paul argues in Romans 11:1-2 ASV, God's calling is irrevocable. The difference in interpretation often hinges on whether the messianic promises remain strictly national or whether they open into a universal kingdom where the natural branches and the grafted-in Gentiles are one people in Christ. Reformed theology holds that we are brought into the hope of Israel, honoring the root that supports the branches, rather than boasting over them.
Sources
7 works cited
Isaiah 53:1-12 · ASV
Who hath believed our message? and to whom hath the arm of Jehovah been revealed? For he grew up before him as a tender plant, and as a root out of a dry ground: he hath no form nor comeliness; and when we see him, there is no beauty that we should desire him. He was despised, and rejected of men; a man of sorrows, and acquainted with grief: and as one from whom men hide their face he was despised; and we esteemed him not. Surely he hath borne our griefs, and carried our sorrows; yet we did esteem him stricken, smitten of God, and afflicted. But he was wounded for our transgressions, he was bruised for our iniquities; the chastisement of our peace was upon him; and with his stripes we are healed. All we like sheep have gone astray; we have turned every one to his own way; and Jehovah hath laid on him the iniquity of us all. He was oppressed, yet when he was afflicted he opened not his mouth; as a lamb that is led to the slaughter, and as a sheep that before its shearers is dumb, so he opened not his mouth. By oppression and judgment he was taken away; and as for his generation, who [among them] considered that he was cut off out of the land of the living for the transgression of my people to whom the stroke [was due]? And they made his grave with the wicked, and with a rich man in his death; although he had done no violence, neither was any deceit in his mouth. Yet it pleased Jehovah to bruise him; he hath put him to grief: when thou shalt make his soul an offering for sin, he shall see [his] seed, he shall prolong his days, and the pleasure of Jehovah shall prosper in his hand. He shall see of the travail of his soul, [and] shall be satisfied: by the knowledge of himself shall my righteous servant justify many; and he shall bear their iniquities. Therefore will I divide him a portion with the great, and he shall divide the spoil with the strong; because he poured out his soul unto death, and was numbered with the transgressors: yet he bare the sin of many, and made intercession for the transgressors.
American Standard Version (1901) · Public domainExternal link
Heidelberg Catechism Q37
That he, all the time that he lived on earth, but especially at the end of his life, sustained in body and soul, the wrath of God against the sins of all mankind: that so by his passion, as the only propitiatory sacrifice, he might redeem our body and soul from everlasting damnation, and obtain for us the favour of God, righteousness and eternal life.
External link · Free-source search opens Google (ads supported)
Zechariah 12:10 · ASV
And I will pour upon the house of David, and upon the inhabitants of Jerusalem, the spirit of grace and of supplication; and they shall look unto me whom they have pierced; and they shall mourn for him, as one mourneth for his only son, and shall be in bitterness for him, as one that is in bitterness for his first-born.
American Standard Version (1901) · Public domainExternal link
Acts 13:27-52 · ASV
For they that dwell in Jerusalem, and their rulers, because they knew him not, nor the voices of the prophets which are read every sabbath, fulfilled [them] by condemning [him]. And though they found no cause of death [in him], yet asked they of Pilate that he should be slain. And when they had fulfilled all things that were written of him, they took him down from the tree, and laid him in a tomb. But God raised him from the dead: and he was seen for many days of them that came up with him from Galilee to Jerusalem, who are now his witnesses unto the people. And we bring you good tidings of the promise made unto the fathers, that God hath fulfilled the same unto our children, in that he raised up Jesus; as also it is written in the second psalm, Thou art my Son, this day have I begotten thee. And as concerning that he raised him up from the dead, now no more to return to corruption, he hath spoken on this wise, I will give you the holy and sure [blessings] of David. Because he saith also in another [psalm], Thou wilt not give Thy Holy One to see corruption. For David, after he had in his own generation served the counsel of God, fell asleep, and was laid unto his fathers, and saw corruption: but he whom God raised up saw no corruption. Be it known unto you therefore, brethren, that through this man is proclaimed unto you remission of sins: and by him every one that believeth is justified from all things, from which ye could not be justified by the law of Moses. Beware therefore, lest that come upon [you] which is spoken in the prophets: Behold, ye despisers, and wonder, and perish; For I work a work in your days, A work which ye shall in no wise believe, if one declare it unto you. And as they went out, they besought that these words might be spoken to them the next sabbath. Now when the synagogue broke up, many of the Jews and of the devout proselytes followed Paul and Barnabas; who, speaking to them, urged them to continue in the grace of God. And the next sabbath almost the whole city was gathered together to hear the word of God. But when the Jews saw the multitudes, they were filled with jealousy, and contradicted the things which were spoken by Paul, and blasphemed. And Paul and Barnabas spake out boldly, and said, It was necessary that the word of God should first be spoken to you. Seeing ye thrust it from you, and judge yourselves unworthy of eternal life, lo, we turn to the Gentiles. For so hath the Lord commanded us, [saying], I have set thee for a light of the Gentiles, That thou shouldest be for salvation unto the uttermost part of the earth. And as the Gentiles heard this, they were glad, and glorified the word of God: and as many as were ordained to eternal life believed. And the word of the Lord was spread abroad throughout all the region. But the Jews urged on the devout women of honorable estate, and the chief men of the city, and stirred up a persecution against Paul and Barnabas, and cast them out of their borders. But they shook off the dust of their feet against them, and came unto Iconium. And the disciples were filled with joy with the Holy Spirit.
American Standard Version (1901) · Public domainExternal link
Acts 13:27-39 · ASV
For they that dwell in Jerusalem, and their rulers, because they knew him not, nor the voices of the prophets which are read every sabbath, fulfilled [them] by condemning [him]. And though they found no cause of death [in him], yet asked they of Pilate that he should be slain. And when they had fulfilled all things that were written of him, they took him down from the tree, and laid him in a tomb. But God raised him from the dead: and he was seen for many days of them that came up with him from Galilee to Jerusalem, who are now his witnesses unto the people. And we bring you good tidings of the promise made unto the fathers, that God hath fulfilled the same unto our children, in that he raised up Jesus; as also it is written in the second psalm, Thou art my Son, this day have I begotten thee. And as concerning that he raised him up from the dead, now no more to return to corruption, he hath spoken on this wise, I will give you the holy and sure [blessings] of David. Because he saith also in another [psalm], Thou wilt not give Thy Holy One to see corruption. For David, after he had in his own generation served the counsel of God, fell asleep, and was laid unto his fathers, and saw corruption: but he whom God raised up saw no corruption. Be it known unto you therefore, brethren, that through this man is proclaimed unto you remission of sins: and by him every one that believeth is justified from all things, from which ye could not be justified by the law of Moses.
American Standard Version (1901) · Public domainExternal link
Books of Homilies
But here is a great controversy between us and the Jews, whether the same Jesus which was borne of the virgin Mary, be the true Messiah, and true Saviour of the world, so long promised and prophesied of before.
External link · Free-source search opens Google (ads supported)
Romans 11:1-2 · ASV
I say then, Did God cast off his people? God forbid. For I also am an Israelite, of the seed of Abraham, of the tribe of Benjamin. God did not cast off his people which he foreknew. Or know ye not what the scripture saith of Elijah? how he pleadeth with God against Israel:
American Standard Version (1901) · Public domainExternal link
Scripture quotations are from the American Standard Version (1901), which is in the public domain.
